I would argue that the article does not consist solely of the lyrics, and primarily contains information about authorship, date of publication, social impact, etc. Thanks! Ariel ♥ Gold 05:41, 6 September 2007 (UTC) Reply Thank you for the explanation. However, if you have additional questions, I'd suggest asking that administrator nicely on their page for further explanation. And my revert was going on the previous revert from an administrator, Cuchullain, whom I trust to have knowledge regarding what is appropriate to add, and what is not. ♫ Cricket02 05:35, 6 September 2007 (UTC) Reply Well, the specific guideline regarding addition of lyrics is here: WP:NOT#LYRICS. ♫ Cricket02 05:31, 6 September 2007 (UTC) Reply Additional note: The lyrics have been in this article since Feb 2005. It seems these lyrics are probably in public domain and relevant to this encyclopedic article about the song. Where is it written that "this is not a lyric site"? Please see Wikipedia:Lyrics and poetry. There is edit warring over inclusion of the lyrics. 68.21.34.176 07:12, 12 April 2007 (UTC) Reply Many thanks! Link to sample traced (.) and added but (sorry!) moved down according to alphabetic order. She might also be included on the solo list. I think that it should also be noted that Tarja Turunen, former singer of the group called Nightwish, did a lovely rendition of Ellens dritter Gesang, which can be found on the Henkays Ikuisuudesta album. Only the third verse made it into the film Fantasia.
And the best part is: the song also has three verses, like Schubert's original. I've got good news: Rachel Field's version of Schubert's "Ave Maria" is in a rare book that's on reserve at the New York Library of Performing Arts. Suggest to organize the artists into (1) those that sing Schubert's original, (2) those that sing the Latin Ave Maria adaptation of Schubert's composition, (3) those that sing some other lyrics variation of Schubert's compostion.Ġ1:05, 12 August 2006 (UTC) / 20:28, 12 August 2006 (UTC) not the later "Latin Ave Maria adaptation): Recordings of Schubert's original "Ellens dritter Gesang" in German (i.e. The listings in this Wikipedia article are looking to me more and more like uncritical off-loadings of favourites, which is not the purpose of a serious encyclopedia. To compound the muddle, the lyrics page wrongly states that it is "Written by: Charles Gounod". If this is the case, then it ought to be removed from this article.Īlternatively, create a new heading such as "Adaptations of Schubert's music".Ĭeline Dion: If the lyrics are correct and complete, then Celine Dion's version is a medley of material from Schubert's "Ellen's third song" that omits the original third verse (thus robbing the Scott/Schubert song of its heart) and material from the traditional "Ave Maria" prayer.
Liona Boyd: The audio clip (all 20 seconds of it.) does not sound like "Ellens dritter Gesang".
Looks like some more work is needed on the listing(s) to be both appropriate and meaningful! 05:38, 10 July 2006 (UTC) Perhaps the following is intended: Classic Kennedy but there he plays indeed the Bach/Gounod "Ave Maria", neither Schubert's song "Ellens dritter Gesang" (which is the subject of this article), nor the "Ava Maria" adaptation of Schubert's said song. How appropriate is the listing under "Solos": "Nigel Kennedy Gounod"? Perhaps the following is "Ellens dritter Gesang" rather than the Latin "Ave Maria" adaptation: Joan Baez, "Noel": "Ave Maria, sung in German".
(55) U.S.A.Would someone be so kind to indicate the version sung by the various artists listed, namely Schubert's original "Ellens dritter Gesang" or the Latin "Ave Maria" adaptation, for example by adding an asterisk to the names of artists singing "Ellens dritter Gesang"! Many thanks! 00:34, 7 July 2006 (UTC)
#Ave maria schubert maria callas download pdf
2/4 meter (24) 4/4 meter (45) 6/8 meter (33) Animals (27) Articles (85) Baby Songs (20) Children's Songs from England (36) Children's songs in English (70) Chords: 2 chords (47) Chords: 3 chords (39) Christmas articles (27) Christmas lyrics (174) Christmas songs in English (40) Copyrighted (21) England (48) Español: Canciones Infantiles (17) Español: Villancicos y Canciones de Navidad (21) Europe (108) famous quotes (29) Folk Song Lyrics (44) Folk Song Lyrics: American (32) glockenspiel or xylophone for children's songs (43) glockenspiel or xylophone for Christmas songs (30) guitar chords for Christmas songs (43) guitar chords for kids songs (62) Karaoke (122) Lyrics in English (376) Lyrics in Spanish (30) Lyrics to Children's Songs (232) Lyrics to Pop Songs and Film Songs (32) Major (97) North America (49) Nursery Rhymes (85) original composition of Christmas music in public domain (40) PDF Lyrics (456) PDF Sheet music (203) piano tutorials for children's songs (48) piano tutorials for Christmas (44) Preschoolers (64) páginas en español (54) Sing-Along (37) Spain (21) U.K.
0 kommentar(er)
